Clicky

Most recent
 An example of how badger culling in the UK is being cast in a negative light
Added or updated 4 days ago
 Randomised Badger Culling Trial: Was there an overall TB increase in the adjoining lands?
Added or updated 4 days ago
PDF icon Killing thousands more badgers won't eradicate TB in cattle. R Woodroffe. New Scientist. COMMENT. 14 September 2017.
Added or updated 7 days ago
PDF icon THE VACCINATION OF CATTLE AGAINST TUBERCULOSIS. THEOBALD SMITH, M.D. Published 1908.
Added or updated 4 weeks ago
 Is specificity of the skin test over-estimated?
Added or updated one month ago
 Accuracy of the TB test for cattle
Added or updated 2 months ago
 Bovine TB in the UK, England, Ireland, Wales and New Zealand
Added or updated 2 months ago
PDF icon New light on the secret life of badgers. University of Oxford. 17 July 2017.
Added or updated 2 months ago
 Level of spend on culling needed to reduce TB
Added or updated 3 months ago
 Bovine TB in New Zealand
Added or updated 3 months ago
 Bovine TB in GB. Latest SAM data, maps and older VETNET data.
Added or updated 3 months ago
PDF icon Freedom of Information Response. APHA. ATIC1096. 9 June 2017
Added or updated 3 months ago
PDF icon Author: HarrisM1
Added or updated 3 months ago
PDF icon First Tier Tribunal (Information Rights). GRC & GRP Tribunals. Government Legal Department. Appeal EA.2017.0030. 9 May 2017.
Added or updated 3 months ago
PDF icon First Tier Tribunal (Information Rights). GRC & GRP Tribunals. Government Legal Department. Appeal EA.2017.0030. 29 March 2017.
Added or updated 3 months ago
PDF icon INTERNAL REVIEW RESPONSE. APHA. ATIC00861. 28 June 2016.
Added or updated 3 months ago
PDF icon Freedom of Information Response. APHA. ATIC00861. 2 June 2016.
Added or updated 3 months ago
PDF icon Specificity of the comparative skin test for bovine tuberculosis in Great Britain. A. V. Goodchild et al. British Veterinary Association. Veterinary Record Volume 177, Issue 10. Accepted July 27, 2015.
Added or updated 3 months ago
 A critique of the Randomised Badger Culling Trial (RBCT)
Added or updated 4 months ago
 Bovine TB map of Great Britain
Added or updated 4 months ago

How politics trumped science when designing the RBCT badger culling trial

Professor Bourne ... Let me take you back to 1999 when we started this work. It was made very clear to us by ministers of the day-and they have not refuted it since-that elimination of badgers over large tracts of the countryside was not an option for future policy.
Q78 Mr Cox: Is it not the function of science-?
Professor Bourne: It was on that basis that we designed the trial. We also had to take into account welfare considerations with respect to method of culling used and limitations on culling with respect to ensuring that cubs were not killed or died underground.
Q79 Mr Cox: You had a closed season.
Professor Bourne: Yes. Those were the clear, political limitations that we operated under. I have no reason to believe that those political limitations have been changed.
Q80 Mr Cox: You make an extremely fair point. That of course does not always come out in the publication of your results. Is it not the function of science to present a list of options to the Government and allow the politicians to decide what is politically unacceptable? The danger about the interpretation of your report from those who are listening to this and reading it is that you have concluded, as a matter of science, that it can be of no effect. In fact, your conclusions are substantially affected by political and social limitations imposed on them.
Professor Bourne: We repeatedly say "culling as conducted in the trial." It is important we do say that. Those limitations were not imposed by ourselves. They were imposed by politicians.
1

References

  1. Badgers and cattle TB: the final report of the Independent Scientific Group on Cattle TB. Fourth Report of Session 2007-08. House of Commons Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee. Volume II. Oral and written evidence. Published on 27 February 2008.
If you would like to send to me your comments, please contact me
Last Modified 07 May 2017 07:55
Javascript is disabled