Clicky

Cookies policy

Basis on which Hilary Benn decided not
to include badger culling in policies to control bovine TB

Most recent
additions and updates
 The political problem
Added or updated 3 weeks ago
 Accuracy of the TB test for cattle
Added or updated 4 weeks ago
 Prevalence of bovine TB in Wales, England, Scotland and Ireland
Added or updated one month ago
 TB restricted herds in the Irish Republic by county
Added or updated one month ago
 TB restricted herds in England by county
Added or updated one month ago
 TB reactor cattle in the Irish Republic by county
Added or updated one month ago
 Level of spend on culling needed to reduce TB
Added or updated one month ago
 Bovine TB in Ireland
Added or updated one month ago
 Bovine TB in the UK, England, Ireland, Wales and New Zealand
Added or updated one month ago
 How politics has trumped science in the current Welsh bovine TB policy
Added or updated one month ago
PDF icon Summary of badger control monitoring during 2016. Updating of minimum and maximum numbers during the cull. Annex A2. DEFRA. December 2016.
Added or updated 4 months ago
PDF icon Summary of badger control monitoring during 2016. DEFRA. December 2016.
Added or updated 4 months ago
PDF icon Bovine Tuberculosis in Wales. A Record of Proceedings in the Senedd. The Climate Change, Environment and Rural Affairs Committee. National Assembly for Wales. Presenters: Fenwick, Wright, James, Howells, Byrne, Wilberforce, Hovi, Livingstone. 8th Dec 2016
Added or updated 4 months ago
PDF icon Setting the minimum and maximum numbers in West Gloucestershire and West Somerset for Year 3 of the badger cull. DEFRA. Advice to Natural England. August 2015.
Added or updated 4 months ago
PDF icon Unknown impact of reactive culling in the RBCT trial. Bovine Tuberculosis in Wales. The Climate Change, Environment and Rural Affairs Committee. National Assembly for Wales. The Record of Proceedings in the Welsh Senedd on 08/12/2016.
Added or updated 4 months ago
PDF icon Funding arrangements for TB control in New Zealand. Bovine Tuberculosis in Wales. The Climate Change, Environment and Rural Affairs Committee. National Assembly for Wales. The Record of Proceedings in the Welsh Senedd on 08/12/2016.
Added or updated 4 months ago
PDF icon Bovine Tuberculosis in Wales. A Record of Proceedings in the Senedd. The Climate Change, Environment and Rural Affairs Committee. National Assembly for Wales. Presenters: Rosie Woodroffe, Gareth Enticott, Neil Paton. 10th Nov 2016.
Added or updated 4 months ago
 Bovine TB in GB. Latest SAM data, maps and older VETNET data.
Added or updated 5 months ago
PDF icon An update on methods for finding TB infection in badger faeces. TB Hub. September 2016.
Added or updated 5 months ago
PDF icon Badger Control Model for Wales - Trap-Test-Cull-Vaccinate. Supplemental Report - 4th March 2009. D. Wilkinson, G.C. Smith. Central Science Laboratory, Sand Hutton, York, YO41 1LZ. Last modified: 20/03/2009.
Added or updated 5 months ago

Badger culling

This presents the basis on which Hilary Benn decided to oppose the culling of badgers in July 2008.

For documents relating to current DEFRA policy, please refer to the DEFRA web site.

In the Final Report of the Independent Scientific Group on Cattle TB released in June 2007 it says

"We wish to commend Defra for supporting the science programme recommended to it by the ISG. Defra is fortunate to have scientific expertise available at the Veterinary Laboratories Agency (VLA) and the Central Science Laboratory (CSL), and research programmes which are of high international standing. However, we have concerns, previously expressed, concerning the capacity of Defra policy groups to translate scientific findings into policy. This we consider stems, in part, from Defra's own organisational structures which we believe enforce a separation of policy development and the scientific evidence on which policy should be based."

In Hilary Benn's statement to the House of Commons on 7 July 2008, Hilary Benn said the following

"The ISG's final report, published last year, concluded that reactive culling killing badgers in areas where there had been local TB breakdowns made the problem worse; and that proactive culling, which involves taking an area of about 100 sq km and repeatedly culling badgers over a number of years, produced only marginal benefits because although TB was reduced in that area, it increased outside of it because of the disturbance and movement of badgers."

Hilary Benn then went on to say

"badger culling cannot meaningfully contribute to the future control of cattle TB".

Work funded by DEFRA at Imperial College London and accepted on 09Apr08 investigated the effects of badger culling following the cessation of culling in the trial areas used in the ISG work reported above. The report shown in Reference 1 states that the final culls were completed in October 2005 and then goes on to say the following.

"Analyses revealed that, during the post-trial period, the incidence of confirmed cattle herd breakdowns was 54% lower inside proactive trial areas than inside survey-only areas. This result was consistent across all ten triplets. However, this effect in the post-trial period was substantially greater than that observed in the during-trial period (23% reduction). There was no evidence of a difference between the effect in the latter part of the trial (last two years during trial) and the first year of the post-trial period.

On land neighboring proactive trial areas, no detrimental effects were observed in the post-trial period: the incidence of confirmed cattle herd breakdowns was 23% lower than that on land neighboring survey-only trial areas. However, again, the effect in the post-trial period was significantly different from the detrimental effect (24% greater incidence) observed in the during-trial period. As with inside trial areas, there was no evidence of a difference between the effect in the latter part of the trial (last two years during-trial) and the first year of the post-trial period."


On 06Nov 08, Jane Kennedy the Minister of State for Farming and the Environment said in the House of Commons that the results in this follow-on work was fully considered by the Secretary of State when he made his decision in July.

Is the decision on badger culling an example of a case where, as inferred by the Final Report of the Independent Scientific Group on Cattle TB, Defra has wrongly translated scientific findings into policy? Although the ISG may not consider the decision on badger culling to be one such instance, their final report does go on to say that they believe that Defra's own organisational structures enforces a separation of policy development from the scientific evidence on which policy should be based.

References
  1. The effects of annual widespread badger culls on cattle tuberculosis following the cessation of culling
If you would like to send to me your comments, please contact me
Last Modified 25 Nov 2012 21:23
Javascript is disabled